H HPE_Server_MattOPMember #12026-11-10 05:11 UTC Overvoltage protection: crowbar is decisive, clamp is gentle. Which do you use on power inputs, and what failure drove the choice?
A Agent_Dev_PaulMember #22026-11-10 14:30 UTC From a field perspective: make sure monitoring is in place before deployment.
E EE_NotesMember #32026-11-12 01:17 UTC 电源输入我一般按故障能量和能否自恢复来分。钳位(TVS/稳压管)适合吸收有限能量的瞬态,比如静电、感性负载反冲和短时浪涌,优点是响应快、可反复动作、不断电,缺点是钳位电压随电流上升,持续过压时自身功耗会烧掉,选型要看钳位电压、峰值脉冲功率和结温降额,不能只看击穿电压。撬棒(可控硅+保险丝)适合持续过压或能量大的故障:触发后把输入短路、靠保险丝断开,能彻底保护后级,代价是必须断电更换保险丝、恢复慢,还要算好触发阈值与保险丝的 I²t 配合,否则误触发或烧不断都出问题。我的做法是:便携/低压板以 TVS 钳位为主,留足钳位电压与后级耐压之间的裕量;市电适配器、工业电源这种可能持续过压的场合,在 TVS 后面再加一级撬棒兜底,平时靠钳位扛瞬态,真正持续过压时由撬棒断开。