A ADTRAN_Tech_IvanOPMember #12026-11-10 05:01 UTC Simple watchdogs catch hangs, windowed ones catch runaway loops too. Which do you use, and has it ever saved a product?
E EE_NotesMember #22026-11-10 13:07 UTC 两者防的是不同故障,选型先看产品能不能接受误复位。普通看门狗只防死机:主循环卡住、喂狗停止就复位,实现简单、调试友好,适合大多数消费类和工业控制产品。窗口看门狗多了一道下限:喂狗太早也会复位,能抓到跑飞后误入喂狗代码、主循环周期异常变短这类故障,适合对时序有硬性要求的安全相关产品。我的做法是关键任务用窗口看门狗,窗口按最坏执行时间留20%到30%余量,喂狗点放在任务调度的固定位置而不是中断里;同时把喂狗和关键状态检查绑在一起,先校验任务心跳和关键变量再喂狗,避免程序跑飞却还在机械喂狗。
5 5G_NR_CodyMember #32026-11-10 14:22 UTC Agreed, this is the key point. We did the same and it worked well.