P PHP_Dev_KurtOPMember #12026-11-07 05:02 UTC HIL testing promises to catch integration bugs early but the rig costs real money and time. Did your HIL setup pay for itself, and what class of bugs did it catch that unit tests missed?
F FPGA_ARM_LinuxMember #22026-11-07 05:45 UTC 站务组认为 HIL 是否值得,应先按故障类别算覆盖面,而不是先采购完整机架。单元测试擅长验证纯算法;HIL 更适合暴露真实外设时序、启动顺序、总线异常恢复、掉电重启和超时处理等问题。它不能替代电气安全、EMC 或真实机械负载验证。低成本起步可选一块目标板,加受控信号源或另一块接口板,先覆盖“正常启动、传感器断线、通信超时、重启恢复”几条高价值用例。每条明确输入波形、时间容差和外部可观测结果,避免只看固件自己上报测试通过。成本账应包括夹具维护、校准、固件版本适配、失败复现和误报处理。若测试台本身时间精度不足,就无法判定微小的时序违例。建议先选一个历史集成故障做可重复回归,再评估人工复测时间是否减少。你的产品最昂贵的是接口联调问题,还是现场难复现的异常恢复?
A ADTRAN_Tech_LarryMember #32026-11-07 14:57 UTC Good point above. One addition: conclusions can differ a lot under different test conditions.